HarvestH2o Online Community



PRIVACY: We will not sell, rent or share your name with anyone. see policy






Article Archives
Company Info
Conveyance Systems
Floating Extractors
How To Guides
New Products
Non-Water Resources
RWH Active Catchment
RWH Advanced Info
RWH Basic Info
RWH Calculators
RWH Healthcheck
RWH Incentives
RWH New Products
RWH Nonprofits
RWH Passive Catchment
RWH Plumbing Code
RWH Regulations
RWH Research
RWH Resources
RWH Testimonials
RWH Vendors
System Design Services
Tank Calculations
Tank Sizing
Water Audits - Indoor
Water Audits - Outdoor
US Water Standards
Water Books
Water Conservation
Water Films
Water Quality
Water Related News

Article Listing

Is Rainwater Harvesting a Good Investment
Drip Irrigation Basics
Florida Environmental House
Swales and Berms
Use It Twice - Greywater

Rainwater System Component Articles

Pumps or Pressure Tanks

Pump Sizing

Storage Options

Sample Systems

Free Pumping
Off the Grid

Water Conservation Articles

Tale of Two Cities Rainwater Harvesting in Taos
Water - Why Care
Save Energy, Save Water

Water Quality Articles

Chlorination, Part I
Chlorination, Part II
Importance of pH
Is Rainwater Safe
Potable Rainwater: Filtration and Purification
UV Purification
UV and Carbon Filtration

Water Op Eds:

Climate Change Greenest Roof
Water - Why Care


Is Rainwater Harvesting a Good Investment?

by John Hammerstrom and Doug Pushard

Is harvesting rainwater a good investment? We will explore that question in depth in this three-part series, beginning in Part One with a traditional economic payback approach.

The short answer is, yes, rainwater harvesting systems can deliver a good return on investment. In certain areas of the country and the world, catching rainwater for household use is the only cost-effective solution. In locations like central Texas, parts of Northern Mexico, and arid rocky areas where no municipal water system is available and where well drilling can be prohibitively expensive, harvesting rainwater is a smart economic and environmental choice.

Additionally, with rising costs of utility water, rainwater harvesting systems can now make good financial sense for homeowners in high-water-rate areas (e.g., Santa Fe, NM; San Diego, CA, etc.), and we can calculate the payback. For homeowners with monthly water bills of $200 or more, short-term, positive returns can usually be demonstrated, and long-term returns may also be realized through increase in property values. Here we will focus on short-term returns.

Why does rainwater harvesting pay off in the short term?

Higher water rates and new, tiered rate systems (i.e., rate systems that are not flat fees per water used, but tiered so the more water used, the higher the cost per gallon) are frequently making rainwater harvesting systems economically viable. Just a small sample of some of the recent water-rate increases:

Water rates can be expected to continue to increase faster than the rate of inflation, so in more areas rainwater harvesting will make great economic sense. These increases are being driven by population growth and demand, diminishing fresh water supplies, and greater costs to process water to make it drinkable. Increased costs will spur more conservation, but it will also make the option of rainwater harvesting more viable for people (see related articles). As an aside, ironically, because many water utilities’ revenues are tied directly to the sale of water, they often have to raise rates to compensate for improved efficiency and conservation, which creates an upward spiral of cost that benefits the rainwater harvesting argument.

When does a system make good financial sense?

A quick and easy way to answer this question is to determine how soon the investment will pay for itself (i.e., the Payback Period). Then determine if this length of time is acceptable compared to other investments you could make.This method provides a simple comparison tool to weigh one expenditure against another. Similar calculations are often done for other appliances, for example:

  • New refrigerators are significantly more efficient than the previous technology, and depending on the relative efficiency of your old and chosen new fridges and the cost of electricity, the electricity bill savings can “pay for” the new appliance in short order, and continue to deliver the savings for many years.
  • The same calculation is true of replacing an old HVAC unit.
  • New clothes washers save electricity and water, often for a terrific payback.

A cold financial analysis would compare home improvement purchases to investment purchases (i.e., investing money in a mutual fund). Sometimes spending money on a money-saving device may deliver a better return on your investment. The savings will continue to mount for the appliance or rainwater-harvesting system’s lifetime and the savings often accelerate as the cost of the alternative rises (higher water rates).

So calculating the Payback Period is a simple method to evaluate the investment of a rainwater system, given local water rates.

The calculation is:

Payback Period = Amount to be Invested/Estimated Annual Savings

An installed active rainwater system (i.e., with pumps and associated components that are more expensive than passive systems) will typically cost about $3 to $6 per gallon of system size, depending on system specifics (above or below ground, amount of piping required, number of pumps, etc.), not including gutters. The numbers used below are for illustrative purposes and will vary widely for your specific local rainfall, cistern size requirements, water rates, system features, installation costs, etc.

So for example, a 4,000-gallon system might cost $15,000. Assume a household with a current water bill of $200 a month, or $2,400 a year. Over ten years this household would pay $24,000 (10 x $2,400) to the water company, assuming no rate increases! If water rates increase just 3% a year for ten years, the total utility water cost would be $27,513. At 7%, it would equal $33,159. And heaven forbid, at 10%, it would total $38,250!

Assuming that 50% of the total household water use would be replaced by rainwater, then a 4,000 gallon system would pay for itself in 12.5 years at today’s prices.

$15,000 / $1,200 = 12.5 years

At a 3% annual price increase, the payback would be even quicker. The annual value of the utility water saved is $1376 (50% x $27,513 ÷ 10).

$15,000/$1,376 = 10.9 years

At 7%, the payback period is nine years, and at 10%, 7.8 years.

Of course, these calculations assume that your rainwater harvesting system is paid for up front with no financing costs. If you are financing your rainwater harvesting system with an interest bearing loan or credit card, this must be factored in to your Payback Period calculations.

How to compare to other investments

Another way to determine if a system makes good financial sense is to compare it to other investment alternatives.

Which is a better investment: paying $15,000 for a rainwater system that yields $1200 a year in savings, or putting that money in a money market account bearing 4% interest a year?

A 4% interest-bearing account would yield $600 a year on your $15,000 investment, whereas your rainwater system would yield $1,200 a year. To put it another way, a $1,200 annual yield on a $15,000 investment is equivalent to an 8% return.

It is currently unlikely to find a low-risk, interest-bearing investment that returns 8% a year. And the return on a rainwater system will only improve over time as utility water rates rise.

So, not to mention the environmental and societal reasons that we will discuss in subsequent articles, installing a rainwater harvesting system is often simply a good investment.

In Part II of this series we will use a Return on Investment tool to compare rainwater harvesting system investments with other investments. We’ll also review the impact of financing a system. Part III will discuss the indirect financial considerations (intangibles) that could be included in your decision to install a rainwater harvesting system.






How do you harvest rainwater?

Where do you get the water?

What is the best way of harvesting rain?

Why should I harvest rainwater?

Do I need pumps to harvest rainwater?

Can I use drip irrigation or soaker hoses with a rainwater?

How big a yard can I water?

How big are rain barrels?

I want more pressure, how should I raise it?

Can I water my grass with rainwater?

and many more>>


Xerxes Tanks


Fun Facts

Favorite Water Books

Taking on Water

A Great Aridness

Drinking Water

Tapped Out



Copyright © 1990-2016 HarvestH2o, All Rights Reserved 505-603-5498